Comparing Tree Types

Table of Contents

• Container Grown vs Bare Root Trees

• Fruit Trees vs Blossoming Trees

• Autumn Colour vs Wildlife Interest Trees

• Shrubs vs Trees for Small Gardens

• Trees with Winter Attributes

• Checklist: Choosing the Right Tree Type

• Quick Comparison Summary

• FAQs

---

Choosing the right tree can transform your outdoor space — whether you want to create privacy, attract wildlife, add seasonal colour, or simply enjoy the pleasure of growing something long-lasting. But with so many varieties available, knowing where to start can feel daunting. That’s where this guide comes in.

In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll be comparing tree types across several categories — from container-grown and bare root trees to fruiting, flowering, and wildlife-friendly species. Each type offers its own unique advantages, suited to different planting times, soil conditions, and design goals.

You’ll find clear explanations, easy-to-read tables, and expert insights to help you decide which tree type best fits your garden, smallholding, or landscaping project. Whether you’re planting a single ornamental specimen or planning a large-scale screen, this guide will help you make confident, informed choices that thrive for years to come.

---

Container Grown vs Bare Root Trees

When it comes to planting new trees, one of the first decisions you’ll face is whether to choose container-grown or bare-root varieties. These are the two main ways trees are supplied, and while both can produce healthy, long-lasting results, they differ in how they’re grown, transported, and established in your soil.

Understanding these differences will help you select the best option for your project — whether you’re planning a small garden feature, a large-scale hedge, or a woodland planting scheme. Your choice will depend on factors such as planting season, budget, soil preparation, and the speed at which you’d like your trees to establish.

Factor	Container Grown	Bare Root
Planting Season	Any time of year (avoid frost)	October to March only
Establishment Speed	Slower to establish, but strong survival rate	Fast establishment if planted correctly
Initial Cost	Higher due to potting and maintenance	Lower and more eco-friendly
Root Disturbance	Minimal	Must be planted quickly
Examples	Betula pendula, Acer campestre	Fagus sylvatica, Carpinus betulus

Container-grown trees are ideal if you value convenience and flexibility. Because their roots are already established in the soil, they can be planted almost any time of year and are less prone to transplant shock. They’re perfect for adding structure to patios or smaller gardens, where you can position and replant easily as your layout evolves.

Bare-root trees, meanwhile, are the sustainable choice for larger or more cost-conscious projects. They’re lighter to transport, require less packaging, and once planted during dormancy, they quickly establish strong root systems ready for vigorous spring growth. If you’re aiming for hedging, woodland, or large-scale screening, bare-root options deliver the best value and long-term results.

Top Tip: For large landscaping projects, bare root trees from Bowhayes Trees offer excellent value during planting season.

---

Fruit Trees vs Blossoming Trees

Few plants offer more joy in the garden than fruit and blossoming trees. Both bring seasonal colour, fragrance, and structure — yet they serve different purposes and suit different types of gardeners.

Fruit trees reward you with edible harvests and year-round interest, from spring blossom to autumn fruit. Blossoming trees, meanwhile, provide show-stopping floral displays that transform your garden each spring, even if they don’t bear fruit.

When comparing tree types like these, it’s worth considering not only appearance but also long-term maintenance, space requirements, and wildlife value. The right choice will depend on whether you want practical produce, ornamental impact, or a balance of both. For more expert advice, visit the RHS guide to growing trees.

Feature	Fruit Trees	Blossoming Trees
Main Benefit	Edible harvests	Ornamental spring colour
Best For	Kitchen gardens, smallholdings	Decorative planting, driveways
Maintenance	Pruning and pest control are required	Low maintenance
Examples	Malus domestica, Prunus avium	Prunus serrulata, Crataegus x media ‘Paul’s Scarlet’

Fruit and flowering trees both bring charm and purpose to a landscape, but their roles go beyond looks. Fruit trees are a rewarding investment for anyone wanting to harvest their own apples, plums, or cherries while still enjoying beautiful blossoms each spring. They’re also fantastic for pollinators, providing nectar before the fruit develops.

Blossoming trees, on the other hand, are pure elegance. They frame views, define entrances, and add seasonal drama — perfect for ornamental displays where beauty takes centre stage. Many varieties, such as ornamental cherries and crab apples, also bridge both worlds, offering breathtaking flowers followed by small fruits for wildlife.

Quick Fact: Many fruit trees double as ornamental options thanks to their spring blossom.

---

Autumn Colour vs Wildlife Interest Trees

When autumn arrives, some trees burst into dazzling displays of red, gold, and orange, while others quietly support birds, insects, and mammals as food and shelter sources. Both bring invaluable character to your landscape — one through visual drama, the other through ecological balance.

Autumn colour trees are perfect for gardeners who want a striking focal point or seasonal variation, adding depth and warmth to the landscape before winter sets in. Wildlife interest trees, on the other hand, help sustain biodiversity, offering berries, nectar, and nesting opportunities throughout the year.

When comparing tree types for your space, the decision often depends on whether you value vibrant seasonal display or long-term habitat creation — or wish to combine both for a truly dynamic garden. For expert guidance, visit the Woodland Trust’s guide to the best trees for wildlife.

Feature	Autumn Colour Trees	Wildlife Interest Trees
Visual Appeal	Vibrant red, orange, and yellow foliage	Year-round shelter and food sources
Wildlife Value	Moderate	High – supports birds, bees, and mammals
Examples	Liquidambar styraciflua, Acer rubrum	Sorbus aucuparia, Crataegus monogyna
Maintenance	Low	Moderate (may attract leaf litter)

Choosing between autumn colour and wildlife appeal often comes down to what you want your garden to express. Trees with autumn colour create moments of visual impact — from the deep reds of liquidambar to the golden tones of field maple — helping define your landscape’s seasonal rhythm.

Wildlife interest trees serve a quieter but equally vital role. They provide berries, pollen, and nesting sites that sustain ecosystems all year. Species like hawthorn and rowan not only feed birds but also offer stunning foliage and spring blossom, making them a practical and beautiful option for nature-conscious gardeners. Combining both types ensures a garden that’s both vibrant and alive.

Expert Insight: If biodiversity is a goal, explore ornamental trees for wildlife gardens on the Bowhayes blog.

---

Shrubs vs Trees for Small Gardens

Not every outdoor space can accommodate towering trees — but that doesn’t mean you have to miss out on structure, colour, or year-round interest. Shrubs and small trees are ideal for compact spaces, offering many of the same benefits as larger specimens while being easier to manage.

Shrubs can provide dense foliage, seasonal flowers, and privacy without overwhelming your garden. Small trees, meanwhile, add height and architectural presence, helping create layers of texture and interest in limited areas.

When comparing tree types for smaller gardens, it’s worth balancing aesthetics with practicality. Think about mature height, root spread, and light levels to find the perfect fit for your space. For more inspiration, see the BBC Gardening guide to trees for small gardens.

Criteria	Shrubs	Small Trees
Height Range	Up to 2.5m	3–6m (ideal for small gardens)
Growth Rate	Fast	Moderate
Root Spread	Compact	Medium
Examples	Viburnum tinus, Cornus alba	Amelanchier lamarckii, Acer palmatum

When space is limited, shrubs and small trees can completely transform the feel of an outdoor area. Shrubs give you dense texture and variety, allowing for colourful combinations without dominating the space. They’re also easy to prune and shape, so you can keep your layout balanced throughout the year.

Small trees add architectural structure and vertical interest without overshadowing nearby plants. Species like Amelanchier and Acer palmatum are particularly versatile, offering delicate blossoms and stunning seasonal foliage. By mixing shrubs and small trees, you can layer your planting design — creating depth, privacy, and a sense of movement even in the smallest settings.

Top Tip: For compact areas, try multi-stemmed varieties available at Bowhayes Trees.

---

Trees with Winter Attributes

Winter doesn’t have to mean a dull or lifeless landscape. While many plants retreat for the season, some trees truly come into their own — showcasing vibrant bark, evergreen structure, and seasonal berries that brighten the coldest days. Others, like fragrant witch hazels and winter-flowering viburnums, offer unexpected bursts of scent and colour when the garden needs them most.

Planting trees with winter interest ensures your outdoor space remains full of texture, structure, and life even when everything else lies dormant. They also provide valuable food and shelter for wildlife, helping birds and pollinators thrive through the colder months. For expert inspiration, visit the RHS guide to trees with winter interest.

Feature	Example Trees	Seasonal Interest
Coloured Bark	Cornus alba ‘Sibirica’, Acer griseum	Red or peeling bark for contrast
Evergreen Foliage	Ilex aquifolium, Taxus baccata	Year-round colour and structure
Berries or Catkins	Betula pendula, Sorbus aria ‘Lutescens’	Winter food for birds
Fragrant Flowers	Hamamelis mollis, Viburnum bodnantense	Scented winter blooms

Winter gardens don’t have to fade into the background. The right tree choices can provide year-round appeal and even become focal points when other plants are bare. Trees with colourful bark, such as red-stemmed dogwood or paperbark maple, bring instant warmth and contrast against frosty backdrops. Evergreen species like holly and yew maintain structure through winter storms, offering essential shelter for birds.

Scented winter-flowering trees, including witch hazel and viburnum, lift spirits with bursts of fragrance and colour when little else is in bloom. Incorporating a few winter-interest varieties ensures your garden remains engaging throughout the year — full of life, texture, and quiet beauty.

---

Checklist: Choosing the Right Tree Type

Not sure where to start? This quick checklist is designed to help you choose the right tree type for your space and goals. Whether you’re looking for fast results, seasonal colour, or a wildlife-friendly haven, understanding what matters most to you will make it easier to find the perfect fit. By matching your priorities with the right planting option, you’ll create a landscape that looks great and thrives year after year.

Question	What to Consider	Best Tree Type
Do you want fast results?	Need instant structure or screening	Container grown
Are you planting in winter?	Planting during dormancy	Bare root
Looking for edible produce?	Kitchen or orchard planting	Fruit trees
Want a wildlife habitat?	Boost biodiversity	Wildlife interest trees
Need low maintenance?	Smaller space, easy care	Shrubs or winter-interest trees

Top Tip: Read Choosing the Right Tree for Your Garden for a deeper dive into selection factors.

---

Quick Comparison Summary

Still deciding which trees to plant? This quick comparison guide breaks down the key strengths and best uses of each tree type — from bare root and container-grown to wildlife-friendly and seasonal varieties. Whether you’re planning a compact courtyard, colourful border, or a large-scale planting project, this overview makes it easy to identify which option best matches your goals, space, and maintenance preferences.

Category	Key Strength	Ideal Use Case
Container Grown	Flexible planting time	Small gardens, patios
Bare Root	Cost-effective and eco-friendly	Large-scale planting
Fruit Trees	Edible rewards	Kitchen gardens
Blossoming Trees	Seasonal colour	Decorative gardens
Autumn Colour Trees	Foliage display	Aesthetic impact
Wildlife Trees	Habitat creation	Nature-friendly landscapes
Shrubs	Compact & versatile	Borders and small spaces
Winter Interest Trees	Year-round structure	Winter landscapes

---

Each tree type offers its own advantages, helping you shape your landscape in unique ways. Bare-root trees are ideal for cost-effective, large-scale planting and establish quickly when planted during the dormant season. Container-grown trees, on the other hand, give you flexibility — perfect if you want to plant at any time of year or create instant impact in smaller spaces.

For those who love seasonal variety, blossoming and autumn colour trees add vibrant beauty that changes throughout the year, while fruit trees bring both ornamental charm and a practical harvest. If supporting biodiversity is your goal, wildlife-friendly trees and shrubs create valuable habitats for birds, pollinators, and other beneficial species.

No matter your planting goals — privacy, colour, food, or wildlife — choosing the right tree type makes all the difference. At Bowhayes Trees, we offer a wide range of trees and hedging to suit every landscape, along with expert advice to help you plant successfully.

From striking statement trees to hardy hedging and wildlife havens, you’ll find everything you need to bring your outdoor space to life.

---

FAQs

What is the main difference between bare-root and container trees?

Bare-root trees are supplied without soil around their roots and are planted during the dormant season (typically November to March). They’re more affordable and establish quickly once in the ground. Container-grown trees, on the other hand, come with their roots in soil and can be planted at any time of year, making them ideal for flexible or smaller-scale planting.

Which trees are best for wildlife?

Native trees such as Hawthorn (Crataegus monogyna), Rowan (Sorbus aucuparia), and Silver Birch (Betula pendula) are among the best for wildlife. They provide nectar for pollinators, berries for birds, and shelter for a wide range of insects and mammals, helping to support biodiversity all year round.

What’s the easiest tree type for beginners?

Container-grown trees are often the easiest choice for beginners because they’re simple to plant and can be added to your garden at any time of year. Small ornamental trees, such as Amelanchier or Acer palmatum, are also ideal — they’re low-maintenance, adaptable to most soils, and provide beautiful seasonal interest without requiring specialist care.

When should I plant bare-root trees?

You should plant bare-root trees during the dormant season — typically from late autumn to early spring (October to March). During this period, trees are not actively growing, which helps their roots establish more easily before spring growth begins.

Can I mix tree types in one garden?

Yes, you can mix different tree types in one garden. Combining trees with varied seasonal interest, shapes, and heights creates a more balanced and visually appealing space. Mixing species such as flowering, fruiting, and wildlife-friendly trees also encourages biodiversity, supporting birds, pollinators, and other beneficial wildlife throughout the year.